PART 10: LET'S TRY TO HOLD ON TO THE PAST, YOU KNOW LIKE... MARCH.
I have not set foot in a courthouse since mid-March 2020. I have not appeared live and in-person before any judge, mediator, or tribunal for approaching on now six months. Sure, there have been lots (and lots) of Zoom, Skype, and Teams conferences and mediations. However, during this pandemic there have been no crowded hallways, dirty courtrooms, broken chairs or smelly stairwells. You know, the good stuff.
We know that being socially distant has required trading the old way for a new way of working that involves kids, dogs, and grilled cheeses.
Recently, a judge became angry when a lawyer referred to his ruling as “nonsensical” in the context of a motion for reconsideration. The court was correct that this this kind of language was inappropriate. This is supposed to be “gentle-persons” practice and that concept seems to have eluded some of us.
All of this brings me to some of the draft proposals that the I have seen for restarting in-person jury trials. In several states they are (to be kind) understandably modest. For example, New Jersey is working on maybe one civil jury trial, in limited counties, towards the end of the year. Likewise, Florida has experimented with online jury trials to some extent. Let’s face it, these ideas are important but progress in moving cases and clearing backlog in the days of this pandemic will be challenging and slow.
Now, the SDL has made proposals for summary bench trials, speed mediations, and creative uses for offers of judgment to address and reduce court backlog. The SDL still endorses these aggressive plans, but the court systems seem to have other ideas about going forward.
As the terrible year of 2020 fades away (we in the Northeast can now also add major power outage to the list of “terribles”), the SDL wonders how long the delis, newsstands, coffeeshops, restaurants, bars, and other businesses that we frequented near courthouses can survive? The good stuff-- all the things not taught in law school in the physical practice of law, is at risk of fading away to the online practice of law.
For now, there is no doubt we need to stay at a distance. No one understands it more than the SDL, but I don’t have to like it.